delphipsmith: (Default)
[personal profile] delphipsmith
(continuing to try to get caught up with books read this year)  This, apparently, is THE must-read book if you're a thirteen-year-old girl, or so I heard.  Which didn't inspire me to want to read it.  But then my colleagues -- one in her 20s, one in her 30s -- started talking it up, so I caved.  On the whole, glad I did.  The writing is a bit uneven and it irks me that Meyers dumps any part of traditional vampire lore that's inconvenient for her plot, but the characters are excellent and the writing has moments of true excellence.  Best bits: dialog, description, both of which are consistently good and sometimes really extraordinary.  Biggest beef: the excessively angsty nature of the vampire boy/human girl relationship.  OK, he's trying to restrain himself from biting her but why not go ahead and sleep with her?  What's the holdup?  Their arguments over her wanting him to change her into a vampire center around his not wanting her to lose her soul (yet Edward's not religious nor is Bella, and it doesn't seem to occur to him that if all the other vampire lore is wrong this one might be too) and her desire not to get old and ugly while he stays young because then he'll leave her (an understandable motive for a 17-year-old girl but a bit thin, really). 

Also, it's hard to see why he needed to be a vampire other than to sex up the storyline.  He can go around in daylight, he's not bothered by garlic or running water, he can choose not to bite her -- oh, but they have to be really careful because a) his teeth are coated in poisonous venom (and yet they kiss A LOT) and b) he's a lot stronger and might accidentally hurt her (yet they do all kinds of things together and he rescues her from imminent death at least once without hurting her).   He gets turned on by the way she smells and has to control himself all the time -- he could be HIV positive and it would have had a lot of the same issues, but not been nearly as sexy.  (I get annoyed by the current trend of inserting mythical creatures into all genres left, right, and center.  I mean, who would have thought there was a market for wolf porn (romance novels in which one party is a werewolf) ??)

All things considered I really enjoyed the book, though; it's a great read and if you can ignore the manufactured nature of some of the issues between them and the occasional SOC (Stupid On Cue) action it's a lot of fun.  I've read the second one but will save that for another entry...

Date: 2009-02-09 06:17 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] nursedarry.livejournal.com
So, with all that contrivance, when will the film version of HSU come out? We're more contrived than all of that and with a much better plot.

Er...

Date: 2009-02-10 01:58 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] kilter.livejournal.com
Bring on the wolf porn! LOL I don't want my porn based in any sort of reality whatsoever.

You're spot on with this. I really enjoyed Twilight. The subsequent books in this series not so much, and progressively less so as they went on.

But Meyer's explanations for everything are ridiculous. She even fell all over herself to explain that their kissing was VERY chaste when someone questioned her about the poison, no tongues, no nuthin'. Yeah, right. Teengers + chaste kissing = I don't think so.

Profile

delphipsmith: (Default)
delphipsmith

December 2022

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
1819202122 2324
2526 2728293031

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated 16 June 2025 11:57 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios